The debate "There are only two genders" was started by
October 26, 2018, 3:49 am.
83 people are on the agree side of this discussion, while 57 people are on the disagree side.
That might be enough to see the common perception.
It looks like most of the people in this community are on the agreeing side of this statement.
kh2g12p posted 1 argument, P627 posted 1 argument to the agreers part.
Brynn posted 11 arguments, Nemiroff posted 4 arguments, crispsandchips posted 1 argument, US7 posted 1 argument, jrardin12 posted 2 arguments to the disagreers part.
Big_Tuna, Runtz, Kanwal, xenophon00, Aceabdu2, Emihle, P627, arjitjha, PansectionalPurity, Jakellutis, Matt, brauliogtz, emily, Argnier555, wilsoergel76, Debatedaddy, happy and 66 visitors agree.
username, TheExistentialist, NitinTher, Nemiroff, crispsandchips, Brynn, sidhant, Argumentative_Folf, US7, mohamnad, jrardin12, rainbowsocked and 45 visitors disagree.
sex: male or female
we all agree about sex. at least as far as humans go.
it is gender that has a soexteym5
jradin you just admitted to using an outdated definition before a lot of scientific progress and knowledge was gathered on the subject. And logical bomb you're using the definition of sex
logical bomb that's just false... look at parrot fish
gender is within the dna , changing organs doesn't do anything
Actually I used the 1913.
jrardin... I googled it. using Webster Merriam... and that is not what I found. You're straight up lying.
Sex, male or female. Webster-Merriam.
it is easy. that's sex, not gender.
it's easy if you have a penis you're a man if you have a vagina you are a woman... come on!!!
Accept proudly the 3rd form of gender by it's on name rather than hiding it
I agree with you now although I think scientists and doctors have a chance of figuring out how to efficiently change someone's sex organs while maintaining their function which is why I make the distinction. I also compare it to hair dye. If a person dyes their hair purple you'd say they have purple hair. Even though they have to constantly redye their hair to make it appear permanent. Its not the best comparison but to me it shows how you would describe someone using their gender and not sex. Like if you saw Blaire White walking down the street you'd probably use female pronouns.
I said it is not a physical characteristics, and I don't see how sex can change after birth. sex change surgery is cosmetic, like amputation or prosthesis. it doesnt change what you are. and hormone replacement isnt permanent. so sex seems pretty set from birth to death.
Let me say this though. There are three main genders male, female, and nonBInary. So yes there are two genders in the sense that all the other genders either exist in between the male female spectrum or exist outside of it when someone doesn't feel like either.
Also XX and XY only determine sex at birth.
Well gender isn't necessarily a physical characteristic so we disagree on the definition.
I could describe the difference but not 30 genders, that's too much for me to remember
as far as humans go, can you name any of these alternative genders? because if you look them up they will be terms like androgenous which clearly describe personality and not an actual physical characteristic.
gender is how you Express yourself on the masculine to feminine spectrum. prince and freddy mercury are both extremely feminine even tho they are clearly men.
androgenous people, for example, act and dress in gender neutral ways which make it difficult to tell what they are, but they are still their sex and can be either gay or straight. they just don't act like the societal gender norm.
as for the definition of sex, very easy: XX, XY. except for rare, mostly sickly mutations.
all that those right wing memes like attack helicopter are completely ignorant jokes that would be funny if those were the lefty stance, but things are only funny if their true, and they are just plain stupid to anyone who actually understands the issues. dont drink the kool aid.
make cuttlefish* excuse me
Well my definition as a biologist for sex is the function of an organisms reproductive organs. Gender is how it expresses itself. Express not in the way we usually think about it. For example make cuttlefish will express themselves as female and trick other males into mating with their females. When they do this their gender changes because they are expressing as female rather than make but their sex is the same because well the function of their organs remained the same. In this sense gender becomes a spectrum between the two points of male and female. So technically their are infinite genders although like there are technically infinite colors between blue and red we still name colors like purple and lavender.
Could you name at least 30 genders or explain to me the distinct difference between gender and sex?
There are organisms with a distinct third gender as well.... and you didn't specify that it's only humans.... we aren't the only animals buddy
so this is factually wrong twice over. We have 2 distinct biological sexes (male and female) and then we have an infinite number of genders. Gender and sex are not synonymous nor interchangeable.